The Fox network in the US is notorious for not properly supporting their shows, upsetting their schedules and canceling shows before they've had a chance to reach their audience or find their footing. And the reason I think people notice this - and remember it, is because Fox puts to air some very inventive and creative programming which appeals to a small but passionate audience. Fox has traditionally upset its science fiction viewers and now it's courting a whole new audience - musical theatre fans and glee club geeks.
Now, to be fair, the pilot will be aired this Tuesday night on the back of Fox's powerhouse ratings bonanza, America Idol - which is actually more about marketing than real musical talent. That said, it has been responsible for Clay Aiken - who went to Broadway in 2008 with Spamalot. So it's a good strategy to pair these two together - although a preview months before the show starts is questionable.
But forget the network and its potential to screw up the most inventive television imaginable. Is their new high school musical series any good? Hell yes!
First key ingredient - cast actors who can actually sing. Lead actor Matthew Morrison - who plays teacher Will Schuester - is a Tony-nominated performer (for The Light in the Piazza) and has appeared in Footloose and The Rocky Horror Show. Actress Lea Michele created the role of Wendla Bergman in the musical Spring Awakening, for which she was nominated for a Drama Desk Award.
The promise of other Broadway names as guest stars went unfulfilled in the pilot, but we have Kristen Chenoweth, Debra Monk, Cheyenne Jackson, Victor Garber and John Lloyd Young to look forward to. Singer Josh Groban, too.
The rest of the cast is filled out with a good mix of comic and dramatic actors - all fitting well into their so far not-too-complicated roles. Just as we would expect from an American high school series, we must deal with jocks and geeks and cheerleaders and nerds as shorthand for who these kids are - with only Finn trying to have a foot in more than one camp at once.
More interesting to me is the way the teacher roles have been written - reflecting on the roles they played in high school (Will was in Glee club then, his wife Terri was one of the popular girls - and they were high school sweethearts) and how little can change in the way some types of people treat other types of people. The unsure football coach trying to ask out another teacher is a cool twist on the typical high school version of it - and not too far removed, particularly in his reaction.
The highlight, as should be expected in a show called Glee, is the music used. To introduce character: Chicago's "My Celophane Man" for Kurt; Les Miserables' "On My Own" for Rachel; "RESPECT" for Mercedes and "I Kissed a Girl" for Tina. As spectacles: "That's the Way" and "Rehab". And to tell a story "Leaving on a Jet Plane" and "Don't Stop Believing".
It's not exactly a musical musical - the characters don't burst into song unless they are on stage, but the music and the rhythm is part of the characters. Rachel needs it because it makes her feel special. Finn does because it makes him feel better and stand out.
Much of the first episode is about characters making decisions based on what's expected of them versus what they feel like they really want to do. And as with most pilots, the audience needs to embrace the fact the story will play out in a certain kind of way - Will will get to teach Glee and remain at the school, even if both are in question at various points in this debut episode. What's interesting is the focus on character and particularly the relationship between what you want in high school and what you get later on. And whether those two things can ever co-exist.
Hopefully the good word-of-mouth and the post-Idol premiere will encourage Fox to let this show find its voice. Because it already sings pretty well so far. Without even trying, it already hits a high B.
Now, to be fair, the pilot will be aired this Tuesday night on the back of Fox's powerhouse ratings bonanza, America Idol - which is actually more about marketing than real musical talent. That said, it has been responsible for Clay Aiken - who went to Broadway in 2008 with Spamalot. So it's a good strategy to pair these two together - although a preview months before the show starts is questionable.
But forget the network and its potential to screw up the most inventive television imaginable. Is their new high school musical series any good? Hell yes!
First key ingredient - cast actors who can actually sing. Lead actor Matthew Morrison - who plays teacher Will Schuester - is a Tony-nominated performer (for The Light in the Piazza) and has appeared in Footloose and The Rocky Horror Show. Actress Lea Michele created the role of Wendla Bergman in the musical Spring Awakening, for which she was nominated for a Drama Desk Award.
The promise of other Broadway names as guest stars went unfulfilled in the pilot, but we have Kristen Chenoweth, Debra Monk, Cheyenne Jackson, Victor Garber and John Lloyd Young to look forward to. Singer Josh Groban, too.
The rest of the cast is filled out with a good mix of comic and dramatic actors - all fitting well into their so far not-too-complicated roles. Just as we would expect from an American high school series, we must deal with jocks and geeks and cheerleaders and nerds as shorthand for who these kids are - with only Finn trying to have a foot in more than one camp at once.
More interesting to me is the way the teacher roles have been written - reflecting on the roles they played in high school (Will was in Glee club then, his wife Terri was one of the popular girls - and they were high school sweethearts) and how little can change in the way some types of people treat other types of people. The unsure football coach trying to ask out another teacher is a cool twist on the typical high school version of it - and not too far removed, particularly in his reaction.
The highlight, as should be expected in a show called Glee, is the music used. To introduce character: Chicago's "My Celophane Man" for Kurt; Les Miserables' "On My Own" for Rachel; "RESPECT" for Mercedes and "I Kissed a Girl" for Tina. As spectacles: "That's the Way" and "Rehab". And to tell a story "Leaving on a Jet Plane" and "Don't Stop Believing".
It's not exactly a musical musical - the characters don't burst into song unless they are on stage, but the music and the rhythm is part of the characters. Rachel needs it because it makes her feel special. Finn does because it makes him feel better and stand out.
Much of the first episode is about characters making decisions based on what's expected of them versus what they feel like they really want to do. And as with most pilots, the audience needs to embrace the fact the story will play out in a certain kind of way - Will will get to teach Glee and remain at the school, even if both are in question at various points in this debut episode. What's interesting is the focus on character and particularly the relationship between what you want in high school and what you get later on. And whether those two things can ever co-exist.
Hopefully the good word-of-mouth and the post-Idol premiere will encourage Fox to let this show find its voice. Because it already sings pretty well so far. Without even trying, it already hits a high B.


Comments
I really liked all the juxtapositions. How Rachel singing "On My Own" worked on several different levels, for example. On the one hand, the lyrics are a pretty accurate reflection of her own sadness, loneliness, etc., but at the same time, the confidence with which she sings exudes the facade that she is happy and talented and special, as does her monologue. But what she says is contrasted with the cheerleaders mocking her on YouTube and the drink poured in her face. So the song reveals itself to be accurate again. I was particularly impressed with that sequence.
But throughout I really liked how tiny little scenes were shown to reveal things about the characters, like the former glee teacher selling pot to the high school coach. It reminded me a little of "Weeds," a little bit of "Election," but overall, it's more optimistic. There's a biting-ness to the humor (loved that spot-on joke about the first time we went to war to fight Bin Laden, for example), which thankfully keeps it from being sappy...but it also allows for the show to get away with a very idealistic message without being treacly. It's a great balance.
And the music...well, it's been stuck in my head all day. And I'll most likely be watching it a few more times over the next few months before it returns.
I really like that Will's relationship with his wife is kind of prickly and that the pregnancy wasn't a completely joyful moment, which turns that type of scene on its head. It's an uncomfortable relationship to watch - and one I didn't think would last long, except for the fact she's pregnant now.
And the other teacher drawing the love heart around his face in the high school magazine - such a high school thing to do!
I'm so grateful that they've cast a couple of really good singers in there, since Hollywood seems to insist on making musical movies with non-singers. At least this series is getting that right.
I've seen some discussion about why it's on Fox, as a few posters think this doesn't seem Fox's kind of show - and that was the reason I assumed i.e. Nip/Tuck is on FX and Ryan Murphy already has a relationship with them.
But yes, the FX - Ryan Murphy - Fox connection does clear things up a lot!
losersless talented people get the chance to have months of practice and training in order to be slightly better than they were before, so that they could get the part.But seriously, I haven't enjoyed a pilot so much in a long time and I was bouncing about hoping you liked it as much.
I'm another one that agrees that it has an air of Election about it, but apparently Rachel is supposed to have an air of Tracey Flick about her - so it's good that people are picking up on that.
I also love the iTunes marketing strategy. All that would have happened anyway was what immediately happened with the pilot - there are ripped copies of tunes floating about the ether because people fell in love with them. "Leaving on a Jet Plane" is something I'm seeing so many people commenting about it's unbelievable.
I read an interesting review that was linked to over on the comm that said this one may well go to either extreme and be an amazing success for Fox or just bomb totally. I get why they might think that, but if they hook us into caring about these characters, and all evidence from the pilot that they'll succeed, then I think this one could be big. Plus, looking not just at the cast but also the guest star list - damn, it's good.
And I'm still having a nutty about the fact that KC is singing three numbers! Yayness!
A few years ago I refused to try a new Fox show unless I knew it got a full season. I stuck to that until this year and tried Dollhouse (because of Joss Whedon) and Glee (because musical!), because every Fox's reputation couldn't put me off those.
I think it's a great pilot, but Fox doesn't always know what it has until it's gone. And as excited as I am about the guest stars, I'm not sure KC and Victor Garber and even Josh Groban translate into huge ratings.
I wish TV networks would nurture shows with a more narrow demographic, because certainly musical theatre geeks (like science fiction nerds - hey, I can say that, I'm both) are very dedicated and loyal.
Fox has renewed a bit of my faith in them by renewing Dollhouse and Bones (for 2 more seasons).
I think it is a very smart move. I'm assuming they'll re-air the pilot when the new season starts and market that as a whole new show. This is just a great way to get the show off the ground and get it out there with people talking about it, so then they have a base to launch off next year rather than going in as one of a bunch of totally new shows.
I loved it, thought it was so brilliant and I can't wait for it to come back!